Skip to content
Locals Japan
GuideTravel Tips & Honne

Getting Around Japan, According to the Japanese Who Ride It Every Day: 17 Comment Sections on the Shinkansen, the Airport Trains, Taxis and the Rules on Board

日本の移動、毎日乗っている日本人の答え —— 新幹線・空港アクセス・タクシー・車内の作法を17のコメント欄で読む

NationwideShinkansenTrainsTokyoKyotoOsakaHiroshimaHakone
Getting Around Japan, According to the Japanese Who Ride It Every Day: 17 Comment Sections on the Shinkansen, the Airport Trains, Taxis and the Rules on Board
“It can add up to longer than the time you spend on board.”
— 106 likes in a 790-comment Japanese thread on flying Hiroshima to Tokyo instead of taking the shinkansen (translated)

Between 27 August and 16 September 2026 we logged every new thread on the two largest English-language Japan travel forums, 931 in three weeks, and 218 of them, almost one in four, name a way of getting around: the shinkansen, the train from the airport, a suitcase that has to go somewhere, a taxi that will not come. The English answers to those questions are timetables and fares. Japanese comment sections answer them differently, because Japanese riders are not choosing a train, they are sharing it with everyone else on board. Across 17 threads and 12,013 comments we have translated, reading the most-liked 2,590, they argue about which station you board at, what the escalators at Tokyo Station cost you, whether you announce a recline or ask for one, and why the taxi app stays quiet. This is the transport half of the ledger: what English speakers asked in three weeks, and what Japanese riders had already settled.

One pattern runs through all of it. Where an English guide gives you a duration, a Japanese rider gives you the part of the journey that is not on the vehicle. The most useful sentence in the Hiroshima thread is about check-in, buses and baggage rather than flight time. The Narita Express versus Skyliner argument is decided by a staircase. The shinkansen threads are about the people in the unreserved car, not the train. Eight questions, in roughly the order the forums ask them, then how we counted.

1. The JR Pass, asked in 10 posts: Japanese rail fans think it was underpriced, and would buy something else

Ten posts in the ledger name the Japan Rail Pass, usually as a yes-or-no question. The Japanese thread under a rail-news channel's coverage of the roughly 70 percent rise in 2023 does not treat it as one. Its two most-liked comments defend the increase: "It was too cheap before, and honestly it's still cheap after the revision, so this is fair." (116 likes), and a second that reads the rise as the industry "moving upmarket on price is reasonable" (115 likes). Nobody in the thread argues that the pass is always worth it. One rider does the arithmetic (14 likes): a Tokyo to Osaka round trip is ¥25,940, so a week that contains two of those pays for the pass and a two-city trip does not. The 7-day ordinary pass is ¥50,000 as of the article's check, and the price sold through overseas agents rises to ¥53,000 from 1 October 2026, so the arithmetic tightens again.

What the thread recommends instead is the part English forums rarely reach. "From here on you'll need to actually research which pass fits your trip. Same as it's always been for us Japanese, to be fair." (13 likes). The rider who priced the round trip adds that "if you pick the right regional pass for the area you actually want to see, you can still travel cheaply" (14 likes), and a commenter planning from Kansai Airport puts the rule the other way round: "the shorter your trip, the more attractive each JR company's regional area pass becomes over the nationwide one" (3 likes). For long hops one rider points at the domestic air fares sold to visitors instead (8 likes). Eight posts in our ledger mention a regional pass at all. If your route is Tokyo, Kyoto and Osaka, the Japanese answer is that you are not the customer the nationwide pass was built for, and the Nozomi supplement, ¥6,500 from Tokyo to Hiroshima as of the article's check, is the other number to know before you buy it.

2. Seats and suitcases, in 35 and 33 posts: reserve both, and only ride unreserved from the origin

Thirty-five posts mention luggage, suitcases or lockers and 33 name the shinkansen, which makes this the most-asked practical cluster after the airport. Zero posts ask about the oversized-luggage rule, and zero ask about boarding at the origin station. Those are the two things Japanese riders would tell you first. The single most-repeated grievance in our transport threads is the space behind the last row of seats on the Tokaido Shinkansen, which is tied to specific seats, free to reserve, and used anyway by people who did not. The most-liked comment in that 633-comment thread: "This has the same smell as people parking in your spot without asking." (575 likes). Then "Fines. Necessary." (460 likes). The rule underneath: bags over 160 cm in total dimensions need a seat with oversized-baggage space, the reservation costs nothing, and boarding without one costs a ¥1,000 fee and a spot the conductor assigns, as of the article's check. If someone's bag is in your space, the practical consensus is "What you can actually do, right now, is tell the conductor immediately." (256 likes). Do not move it yourself: "if the bag gets damaged and they sue you, you lose" (28 likes). One rider with a booked slot says "my case was so heavy I shipped it ahead" (3 likes), which is the quiet answer to the 12 posts asking about luggage forwarding.

The seat question is the same shape. The Nozomi already runs all-reserved in peak periods and unreserved cars are shrinking, and in an 812-comment thread Japanese riders overwhelmingly approve. The most-liked comment (1,124 likes) is a verdict on passengers rather than trains: "The greatest irony: the quality of the trains keeps improving while the quality of the people riding them keeps dropping." The complaint is specific: "in peak season, the overflow floods into the reserved cars and stands in the aisle" (388 likes). The arithmetic is blunt: "why on earth skimp on the ¥540 for a reserved seat?" (41 likes), a fare difference as of the comments. And for the holdouts, the thread doubles as a manual. "Unreserved seats: only ever board at the origin station." (519 likes). "unreserved for short hops, reserved for anything over an hour" (40 likes). "Sit in the Green Car and you're freed from every one of these stresses." (79 likes). Nobody in 931 English posts asked which station the train starts from. Every Japanese rider in this thread knows.

3. The airport train, in 85 posts that name an airport: Japanese riders score it by the stairs, not the stopwatch

Eighty-five posts name Haneda, Narita or another airport, and 12 ask directly how to get from one into the city. It is the transport question that comes up almost every day. The Japanese thread on it is a split-screen race from Narita to Tokyo Station in which the Narita Express arrived first, and the comment section overturned the result. The most-liked reply (202 likes): "Realistically, I think the Skyliner retakes the lead in the time it takes to crawl up from the Sobu Line underground platform at Tokyo Station to street level." Fifty-eight likes for "the Narita Express platform is deep underground". The Skyliner's own weakness is named just as precisely, and it is the transfer: with international luggage "your route through the station gets dictated by where the escalators are and where the doors line up, so the Nippori transfer loses a lot more time too" (21 likes), and "I wouldn't want to ride the Yamanote with luggage" (8 likes).

So the rule Japanese riders arrive at is not about speed. "For getting anywhere north of Ueno, I guess the Skyliner is a bit more convenient." (13 likes). The Narita Express is the train for anywhere it reaches without a change, and the defence of its price is a defence of exactly that: "It was never meant to get you there fast; it's meant to get you there comfortably and on time." (2 likes). One rider maps the onward connections: "The N'EX has the transfer to the Tokaido Shinkansen at Shinagawa, and the Skyliner has the transfer to the Tohoku, Joetsu and Hokuriku Shinkansen at Ueno." (4 likes). The fares as of the article's check: 36 minutes and about ¥2,500 to Nippori on the Skyliner, about an hour and ¥3,140 to Tokyo Station on the Narita Express, or ¥5,200 for the round-trip ticket sold to foreign passport holders since the March 2026 fare change. Pick by where you sleep and how heavy the bag is. That is the whole answer, and it is not on the timetable.

4. Shinkansen, plane or night bus: Japanese riders count the time you spend not moving

Only four posts in the ledger ask the train-or-plane question outright, and one asks about a night bus, but the Japanese threads on both hold the rule of thumb this site quotes most. A video flew Hiroshima to Tokyo against the shinkansen and the plane won the stopwatch. The 790-comment thread handed down the opposite verdict. "I think the probability of a plane being delayed is higher than the probability of the shinkansen being late." (141 likes). The comment this article is named for lists the airport bus, check-in, security and baggage and concludes that "It can add up to longer than the time you spend on board." (106 likes). A rider from Kanagawa took the airport shuttle, "the expressway had a huge jam from an accident and I missed it, and I've gone by shinkansen ever since" (55 likes). The four-hour rule Japanese travelers use, plane beyond four hours of train and shinkansen inside it, is laid out at length by one commenter who then warns that "four hours is only a rough guide" (87 likes). And the detail no English guide prints: "if you've got an EX reservation you can walk through the shinkansen gate one minute before departure and still make it" (14 likes).

The night bus thread splits on sleep rather than money. The most-liked answer picks neither option: "Having the Sunrise Express deliver you to Tokyo while you lie down is fun too" (880 likes), which is the one regular sleeper train left, running Tokyo to Takamatsu and to Izumo. The case against the bus is "a four-across seat with someone next to you and no curtain is rough" (477 likes) and "With the night bus I end up worn out and can't enjoy the destination" (243 likes). The people who still ride it state their conditions: "Three-across is the strongest" (28 likes), and "on a night bus make sure you get off at the rest stops" (19 likes). If you cannot sleep sitting up, this thread says, the hotel night you save buys you a wasted first day.

5. Taxis, in 11 posts: why the car does not come, from the drivers

Eleven posts ask about taxis, Uber or a ride-hailing app. The Japanese thread that answers them sits under a 2026 video on taxi companies going under, and its most-liked comments are written by drivers. Their one request is not about fares. "Booking two rides at once and then cancelling one of them is something you absolutely must never do." (317 likes), because the driver has already raced to your pin for nothing. Zero posts in our ledger mention double-booking; it is the thing the drivers most want visitors to know. The second thing is where the taxis are: "In central Tokyo it's JPN Taxis to the left and right. At night there are overwhelmingly more taxis than ordinary cars." (59 likes). A former Tokyo driver adds that "app dispatch is the main way to earn" (30 likes), which is also why a request can go unanswered. Drivers choose jobs: "if a job comes in on GO and then a better one comes in on DiDi, we cancel the GO one" (17 likes). A working driver's instruction: "Before you send the request, look at how many cars are around you and try them one at a time." (10 likes).

Outside the big cities the answer is different, and Japanese commenters give it bluntly. "A few years ago the taxi company in my hometown shut itself down." (105 likes). "Taxis don't run in the countryside." (3 likes), from someone who walked three kilometres to a client after being told every car was out. The rule that falls out is to book a rural taxi through your accommodation the day before rather than hail it, and in Tokyo to use the app or a raised hand, not both at once. Uber in Japan dispatches licensed taxis on the meter, and central Tokyo fares changed on 20 April 2026 to ¥500 for the first kilometre, with a 20 percent late-night surcharge from 22:00, as of the article's check.

6. Suica, in 11 posts: yes, get one, and know the one trip it cannot make

Eleven posts ask whether they need a Suica or another IC card. Japanese rail fans say yes without much interest, and then spend 665 comments on the failure the English guides skip: no IC card can ride a regular train from one fare region into another on a single tap. The most-liked comment (349 likes) shrugs that "Japan is just bad at unifying anything nationwide". The reason is money, spelled out at 114 likes: a system overhaul across every gate and server would cost hundreds of billions of yen, and each railway has decided it would never recoup it. One rider maps where it bites, Atami and Kozu, Maibara and Kameyama, Shimonoseki (89 likes). Zero posts in our ledger ask about the area boundary, and it is the one thing that strands a tapped-in ticket.

The fixes Japanese riders use are practical. "Long-distance trips are something you plan in advance anyway, so buying a paper ticket doesn't feel like a chore" (26 likes). A Nagoya-to-Osaka traveler found that "you can ride Kintetsu the whole way on ICOCA" (22 likes). And the everyday case: "You can top up a transit IC card at 7-Eleven ATMs, which is handy." (33 likes). For the shinkansen itself, buy a ticket or book online; the card is for the city. Visitors can pick up a Welcome Suica at the main Tokyo stations and both airports, or load a Suica onto a phone, as of the article's check.

7. The rules on board that nobody asked about: zero posts, and the biggest threads we have

This is the finding that repeats from our last column. Across 931 titles and opening paragraphs, the number that ask about reclining a shinkansen seat is zero. Wearing a backpack on your front, zero. Smoking on the shinkansen, zero. Eating on the train or buying food on board, zero. Phone calls on trains, one. Strollers, three. Those six subjects produced six of our largest threads, 5,962 comments between them, and they are the subjects Japanese riders argue about hardest, because they decide whether the car is pleasant to be in.

On phone calls the rule is a request rather than a law, and Japanese riders want it kept. The most-liked comment in a 1,961-comment thread: "If you're fine with some random middle-aged guy next to you cackling into his phone, then sure, go ahead. I'm not, so keep the ban." (1,260 likes). The reason given is volume: "Phone calls tend to get loud, and the person talking can't tell." (979 likes). The move they approve of when your phone rings anyway (253 likes) is to pick up, say quietly that you are on the train, and hang up; the stock line is "Sorry, I'm on the train right now, can we do this later?" (71 likes). On reclining, every English guide says ask. The 824-comment thread says announce. Thirty-four of the 200 top comments use the same script, taoshimasu ne, I'm reclining now, and the second most-liked reply explains why asking is the weaker move: if you ask, the person behind can say no. "You don't need permission from the person behind, but you should declare it." (42 likes). What they do call rude is the surprise: "I once had the tray table down with a coffee on it and the seat in front came back with no warning — the coffee went everywhere." (192 likes). And the limit: "I only take it back as far as it isn't a problem for anyone." (29 likes).

The backpack rule has moved on from the one you were told. Commuters in a 305-comment thread object to the pack left on your back, "If you get on with the pack still on your back, you can hit the person behind you without even noticing and actually injure them." (60 likes), and refuse the overhead rack the operators now suggest: "At any normal company, just putting your bag up on the rack would earn you a written warning." (55 likes). Where you stand matters more than how you hold it: "It's the people doing it in the doorway area who are in the way." (17 likes). On food, the Tokaido Shinkansen's trolley ended on 31 October 2023, and the most-liked explanation is that "Almost every passenger now buys whatever food and drink they want at a convenience store, a station shop or a department-store food hall and carries it on board, so the cart's customers had basically vanished." (137 likes). The famous rock-hard ice cream survives in platform vending machines, and one rider's trick is "I buy it at Tokyo Station and wait until Nagoya." (22 likes). The line between the shinkansen and a commuter train is drawn in Osaka's pork-bun thread, 713 comments in which the top reply rules that "551 isn't unpleasant — it's food terrorism." (1,552 likes) and a rider states the rule: "if it's sold inside the station, it's fine on a limited express or the Shinkansen" (51 likes). Smoking rooms on board closed on 16 March 2024 and the thread barely argued: a business traveler who remembers the old smoking car says "when I picture that sight, I welcome today's move toward non-smoking" (69 likes).

The stroller thread is the one where the rule and the advice point in opposite directions. Japan's transport ministry settled the folding question in 2014: you may keep a stroller open in the marked space. In a 1,921-comment thread Japanese riders barely mention it, because the Tokyo peak hour has no space to give. "People saying the other passengers should just move to a different car don't know what a big-city rush hour is." (525 likes). "If you can get on with a stroller, that's not a packed train anymore, is it." (288 likes). Off-peak the same thread is generous: "On a train that's reasonably empty, I have never once seen passengers fail to clear the dedicated space when a stroller comes in." (100 likes). A Tokyo parent gives the workaround: "At busy times I move by taxi and treat it as a necessary expense, buying safety." (81 likes). And the window is short: "It's only packed until about nine anyway" (32 likes).

8. Hakone, in 60 posts: the Free Pass tricks Japanese riders use, and the fog

Hakone is named in 60 posts, and zero of them mention the Hakone Free Pass by name. The Japanese thread under a ¥10,000 Free Pass day trip reads like a regulars' operating manual. Board the bus one stop early: "From Hakone-Yumoto the buses mean queuing and standing, so I board at Odawara as a matter of course." (6 likes). Walk the park the right way round: "get off at Koen-Kami station, stroll down through the park, and walk out at Koen-Shimo or Gora station" (25 likes). Expect the ropeway to disappoint: "Every single time I go to Hakone, the ropeway is in fog." (11 likes). Bring children, because a commenter flags that the child pass is nowhere near half the adult fare (37 likes), which still holds at ¥7,100 for adults and ¥1,600 for children from Shinjuku as of the article's check. And eat at the station: the most-liked comment (272 likes) is a former staffer of the Odakyu station soba chain, who says "the kakiage fritter is genuinely great, but it loses half its magic if it's not freshly fried", so ask for it fried to order.

The crowd advice from the wider Hakone thread is the one we quoted last week, and it still governs. The creator's pinned conclusion: "shift your timing and you can enjoy Hakone as much as you like — but be careful with Owakudani and the transport home" (685 likes). Owakudani's nature trail is reservation-only guided entry, as of the comments, and the ride home is the part Japanese riders plan around. The quiet alternative is in the Free Pass thread: Chisuji Falls, where "even in autumn, there was nobody else there" (17 likes).

How we counted, and what this does not cover

Every weekday we capture the new-post feeds of r/JapanTravelTips and r/JapanTravel into a local ledger. This article covers what that ledger held on 16 September 2026: 931 unique threads, 650 from r/JapanTravelTips and 281 from r/JapanTravel, captured over the 21 days from 27 August, with posting dates running from 1 August to 16 September. The matching runs over each post's title and the first 400 characters of its text, so every count here is a floor. A post that raises the oversized-luggage rule in its fourth paragraph is invisible to us, and the zeroes are strong only because they survive that window across 931 posts. A post counts as naming a way of getting around when it matches at least one of a list of transport words, from shinkansen and Suica to taxi and airport; 218 posts did, 23.4 percent. The counts are produced by a script published with the site rather than typed by hand, so they can be recomputed.

We count questions, not answers. Nothing here reports what anyone on an English forum replied, and no forum comment is used as a source. Every quote and every like count comes from a Japanese-language YouTube comment section we translated ourselves, and each section links to the full roundup, which links to its source video. Two gaps are worth naming. Thirty-three posts mention renting a car or driving, and we have no Japanese comment section on it yet. And the largest category of all, the 227 posts asking for an itinerary to be checked, is one Japanese comment sections do not answer, for the reason we gave last week: the order of your cities is a problem only visitors have. Fares, fees and dates in this article are the ones the underlying roundups checked against the operators' own pages between July and September 2026, and are marked as of those checks. They will move.

The short version

Reserve two things on the shinkansen, the seat and the space for a big suitcase, and if you gamble on an unreserved car, board where the train starts. Price your real route against a regional pass before you price it against the national one. Into Tokyo from Narita, choose the train by where you sleep: Skyliner north of Ueno, Narita Express for anywhere it reaches without a change, and Narita Express whenever the bag is heavy. Inside four hours of train, take the train; the Japanese rule counts the bus to the airport, and the plane is the one that gets cancelled.

Order one taxi, not two, and outside the cities book it the day before. Tap the Suica in the city and buy a paper ticket for the long haul. On board, announce the recline, take the call in the vestibule, keep the pack off your back in a full car, and eat what the station sold you. Nobody on the English forums asked about those last four. They are the ones that decide how the car feels, and Japanese riders have been deciding them, in public, for years.

More from Japan